In the world of RC cars, the transmitter you choose can make all the difference. Both the SANWA M17 and Futaba 10PX have gained notoriety among racers for their advanced features and design. But which truly stands out when pitted against each other? This article aims to dissect their specifications, garner feedback from the racing community, and present an unbiased comparison to help enthusiasts and racers make an informed decision. Let the showdown begin!
Which is Better? Simple Answer:
Ultimately, choosing between M17 and 10PX comes down to personal preference. Given that the speed and responsiveness of top-tier radios are now so advanced, most drivers might not discern the subtle differences. It’s best to go with what feels right in your hands and suits your specific requirements and budget.
Detailed Basic Comparisons: M17 vs. 10PX
| Feature/Parameter | M17 | 10PX |
| Display | Fine Color Display (480×320) | Full-color HVGA 4.3 inch, backlit LCD touchscreen |
| Response/System Compatibility | Ultra Response Mode (SUR) with FH5 system | F-4G, T-FHSS MINIZ, S.BUS2 |
| Software Updates | Via Micro SDHC Card | Via microSD card |
| Special Features | Detachable Throttle Unit, SSL CODE10 and CODE5 | Brake mixing, steering mixing, 4WS mixing, dual ESCs mixing, etc. |
| Connectivity/Telemetry | Compatible with Micro SDHC Card for updates and telemetry logs | Telemetry with F-4G system |
| Protocols Supported | FH5 | T-FHSS-SR/T-FHSS/S-FHSS/F-4G |
| Receivers Supported | RX-491, RX-492, RX-492i, RX-493, RX-493i | R404SBS and R404SBS-E |
| Additional Functions | Multi-Setting Function, Screen Reader, Quick Set Up Wizard | Throttle speed, Steering speed, Dial select, Switch select |
| Ergonomics | Wheel and trigger adjustability, Left-handed support | Full color HVGA 4.3 inch, backlit LCD touchscreen |
Display & Interface
While both the SANWA M17 and Futaba 10PX offer touchscreen interfaces, the Futaba stands out with its HVGA 4.3-inch, full-color, backlit LCD touchscreen. Users have mentioned that the touch screen on the Futaba is much superior, offering better visibility, responsiveness, and interface design.
Receiver Size
SANWA has the edge when it comes to the size of its receivers. They are generally smaller, which can be beneficial depending on the installation and space requirements in your RC model.
Brand Preference among Racers
Most racers tend to have a preference for SANWA over Futaba. One of the reasons behind this could be that Futaba has fewer sponsorships in comparison. Such sponsorships often influence brand visibility and usage in competitive environments.
Design Longevity
SANWA tends to keep its designs for an extended period. The M11, for example, remained their flagship for nearly a decade. This could indicate the company’s confidence in the longevity and performance of its designs.
Artistic Design vs. Performance
While the M17 is often described as a work of art due to its design and features, it’s essential to note that owning it won’t magically make one a better racer. The key is to find a transmitter that resonates with your needs and driving style. It’s an instrument, after all, and its effectiveness largely depends on the user’s proficiency.
Price & Investment
While Futaba might be on the pricier side when it comes to the transmitter, they offset this with cheaper receivers. SANWA, conversely, tends to have pricier receivers. However, the long-term use and potential advantages of your chosen transmitter should be seen as a long-term investment.
Popularity on Tracks
Despite the introduction of newer models like the M17, many racers still swear by the M12 because of its proven track record and reliability. It’s crucial to understand that success on the track isn’t just about having the latest gear but how well you utilize it.
Speed & Latency
Modern top-end radios, including both M17 and 10PX, offer near-zero latency, translating to incredibly fast response times. To an average driver, this difference in milliseconds is almost imperceptible.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Can I use receivers from other brands with these transmitters?
Both transmitters are designed to work best with their brand-specific receivers. However, certain third-party receivers might be compatible, but performance is not guaranteed.
Do they come with warranties?
Typically, both SANWA and Futaba offer warranties for their products. It’s recommended to check with the retailer or manufacturer for specific warranty details.
Which one has a better response time for competitive racing?
Both transmitters boast extremely quick response times, suitable for competitive racing. The choice ultimately boils down to racer preference and specific model specifications.
Remember, when considering a purchase, always consult the product manual and reviews from trusted sources to ensure you make the most informed decision.
Leave a Reply